• Menu
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Craftsy Soul logo

Inspire • Create • Repeat

DIY Fall Heart Sign

You are here: Home / Autumn / DIY Fall Heart Sign

(Dollar Tree sign makeover)

Hello Sweet Friends,

For today’s craft project, I decided to makeover a Dollar Tree Valentine heart-shaped sign. I don’t really decorate a lot for Valentines Day. In fact, not very much at all. But FALL decorations are only second to Christmas decorations in my home. So I decided that the perfect thing to do was to give this little heart sign and FALL makeover. And I’m so GLAD I did. I hope you like it as much as I do. It’s a very easy and budget-friendly project. Enjoy!

Supply list

  • Dollar Tree heart shaped sign
  • Dollar Tree decorative wall tile
  • Mod Podge
  • scissors
  • white paint
  • brown paint or stain
  • cinnamon
  • fall ribbon, floral, and embellishments
  • glue gun
  • Scrabble tiles spelling out “I LOVE FALL MOST OF ALL,” optional

This particular Valentine sign, had the word love, attached to it. It is made of metal, so I pried it off and set it aside because I thought I might use it for another project later on. Then I traced the heart onto the wall tile, and cut it out.

For the next step, I applied a liberal layer of Mod Podge to the sign, using a sponge brush. Then pressed the wall tile heart on top, and let it dry.

A nice coat of white paint was next, followed by dry brushing with some brown paint. The brown paint gives it a distressed and aged look.

To give the sign a very VINTAGE vibe, the next step was adding cinnamon to it. Start by brushing Mod Podge here and there on the sign, wherever you would like to add a rusty look. Sprinkle with cinnamon, they shake off the excess. Add a top coat of Mod Podge to the entire surface. Then let dry. I love the RUSTY look that the cinnamon adds to the project.

Time to add the final touches. Glue any florals, ribbon, and embellishments toward the center of the heart, keeping the outer edges of the heart visible.

Now at this point, the project could be finished. However I chose to add the short message, I LOVE FALL MOST OF ALL, in Scrabble tile letters. I just hot glued them into place. I also glued a twine hanger onto the back.

I just LOVE how this makeover project turned out! I LOVE everything about it; the rustic wall tile, the muted fall colors, the sweet little fall quote. It really is the PERFECT piece to add to my fall decor this year.

I hope you have enjoyed this project and that maybe I’ve given you some inspiration to create something new for your HOME this fall.

Happy Fall!
and
Happy Crafting!

Pamela

P.S. I think I really do love FALL most of all!

Dollar Tree heart sign gets a fall makeover

Share this:

  • Share
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
Previous Post: « Dollar Tree Foam Pumpkin Makeover
Next Post: Upcycled Glass Jar Jack o’lanterns »

Primary Sidebar

Crafts by Category

  • 10 Minute Crafts
  • Autumn
  • Budget-Friendly
  • Christmas/Winter
  • Coastal Farmhouse
  • Floral Crafts
  • Home Decor
  • Makeover
  • Patriotic
  • Signs
  • Spring/Easter
  • St. Patrick's Day
  • Summer
  • Valentine's Day

Meet Pamela, the Creator

Pamela, Creator

Born and raised in rural, Missouri, I'm a wife of 30 years and mother to one adult son.

My interest in all things artsy-craftsy began as a young girl. If there was a craft kit for it, I've probably tried it: paint-by-number, latch-hooking rugs, candle-making, shrinky-dinks, string-art, etc. I loved them all! For many years I was able to express my creativity on-the-job as a florist, and love using silk florals in my home decorating projects.

I'm excited to share my crafting and home decorating ideas with you. I like finding that perfect thrift store item and crafting something new out of it, or giving that old piece of furniture a new life with a fresh coat of paint. I hope my projects will inspire you to get craftsy and create things to help decorate a home you love.

Happy Crafting!

Copyright © 2025 · Craftsy Soul · Website by Off-Center Design · Log in